Actual vs estimated hours: why jobs run over and how to see it

By Carlos B., Founder, Always On Tradie7 min read

Comparing actual vs estimated hours shows you which jobs ran over, by how much, and why. On a fixed-price job every extra hour comes straight out of your profit, so the gap between the hours you booked and the hours your crew worked is the number to watch each week.

Actual vs estimated hours is the gap between the labour you allowed for a job and the labour it really took. Booked hours are what you planned and scheduled. Actual hours are what your crew worked, from arriving on site to leaving. When actual runs past booked on a fixed-price job, you pay for the difference.

Most trade businesses only find out a job ran over when the profit isn't there at the end of the month, and by then nobody remembers why. This guide shows what an overrun costs, the usual reasons jobs take longer than planned, and a simple weekly check that turns the gap into better quotes.

What are booked hours and actual hours?

Booked hours are the labour hours you planned for a job, usually taken from the quote (or estimate) and used to schedule the crew. Actual hours are the hours worked on that job, recorded at the time rather than remembered later.

  • Booked hours: the time on the schedule, for example two crew members for a full day is 16 hours.
  • Actual hours: the time recorded on the job, ideally from check-in and check-out on site.
  • Variance: actual minus booked. Positive means the job ran over; negative means it came in under.
  • Variance %: variance ÷ booked × 100. A job booked at 16 hours that took 21 ran 31.25% over.

The percentage matters because it lets you compare a half-day call-out with a two-week renovation. Half an hour over on a four-hour job and five hours over on a sixteen-hour job are very different problems.

What does it cost when a job runs over?

On a fixed-price job, every hour over the estimate costs you the wage for that hour and takes the same hour away from paid work elsewhere. The overrun rarely looks big on the day, which is why it adds up unnoticed.

A worked example

Say you quote a bathroom rough-in with 16 labour hours at a charge rate of $95 an hour, so $1,520 of labour on a fixed price. Your labour cost, wages plus on-costs, is $55 an hour. If the job takes 16 hours, labour earns you 16 × ($95 − $55) = $640.

Now say it takes 21 hours. You still bill $1,520, but labour costs 21 × $55 = $1,155, so labour earns $365. Five extra hours cut the labour profit by $275, nearly 43%. Your effective rate dropped from $95 to $72.38 an hour.

That's one job. If the same thing happens on the same type of job every month, the problem isn't the crew, it's the number you're quoting.

Why do jobs take longer than estimated?

Jobs usually run over for a handful of repeatable reasons, and most of them trace back to the estimate or to the day being disrupted, not to people working slowly. The fix depends on which one it is, so record the reason every time.

ReasonWhat it looks like in the numbersWhat to change
The estimate was optimisticThe same job type runs over again and againRaise the hours you quote for that job type
Extra work added on siteOne job runs well over, with work not in the quoteWrite up a variation and get it approved before doing the work
Waiting on materials or accessHours on site with little progressCheck deliveries and access the day before
Supplier runs and travelTime between jobs swallows the dayOrder ahead and send materials to site
Rework or callbacksA second visit on a job you thought was finishedFind the cause and fix it at the source
Crew mixOverruns follow certain combinations of peoplePair newer crew members with experienced ones, and quote for it
Hard siteTight access, old buildings, occupied homesAdd a site allowance to the quote

Extra work deserves its own mention. When the customer asks for one more thing and it gets done as a favour, the hours appear as an overrun even though the job was quoted correctly. If it wasn't in the quote, it's a variation.

How do you track actual vs estimated hours?

Track actual vs estimated hours by putting booked hours on every job, recording actual hours on site at the time, and comparing the two every week. Here is the routine:

  1. Book hours on every job. Take them from the quote, so the schedule matches what you priced.
  2. Record actual hours on site. Check-in and check-out on the job beats a paper timesheet written up on Friday.
  3. Compare weekly. Pick a set time, list last week's finished jobs, and work out the variance and variance % for each.
  4. Write down the reason for anything over your threshold. One line is enough: "waited 2 hours for tiles".
  5. Feed it back. If one job type keeps running over, change the hours you quote for it.

Why paper timesheets hide the problem

A timesheet filled in at the end of the week tends to match what was planned, because people round to what they think the job should have taken. Hours recorded when the crew arrives and leaves show what actually happened, including the time spent waiting.

A weekly review you can copy

Ten minutes a week is enough to spot a pattern. Here is what a week of finished jobs might look like, with example numbers:

Example week. Variance % = (actual − booked) ÷ booked.
JobBooked hoursActual hoursVarianceVariance %
Hot water replacement44.5+0.5+12.5%
Bathroom rough-in1621+5+31.25%
Deck repair87−1−12.5%
Gutter replacement66.5+0.5+8.33%
Fence install1215+3+25%
Total4654+8+17.39%

Across the week the crew worked 8 hours more than booked, 17.39% over. But the total hides where it came from: two jobs account for all of it. Those two are the ones to ask about.

What variance is acceptable?

Set your own threshold, because a fixed-price renovation and a do-and-charge service call carry very different risk. As an example, you might look into anything more than 10% over, or more than two hours over, whichever comes first. The point is to pick a line and check against it every week, not to explain every half hour.

Turn the review into a better quote

Once you have a few weeks of numbers, group them by job type. If bathroom rough-ins ran 31%, 22% and 28% over across three jobs, and the reasons were mostly the same, the estimate is wrong, not the week. Raise the booked hours for that job type in your quote template and watch whether the next few land closer.

Keep one-offs out of it. A job that ran over because the customer added work, or because a delivery came a day late, tells you about that job, not about how you price.

Also watch jobs that come in well under. If a job type is regularly quicker than booked, you may be overpricing it and losing quotes you could have won.

How do I get my crew to record their hours?

Crew record hours reliably when it takes one tap on their phone and when they can see why it matters. Explain that the numbers fix quotes, so the next job is booked with enough time, rather than to catch anyone out.

  • Make it one action at the start and end of the job, not a form to fill in.
  • Put it on the phone they already carry, so nobody needs a separate device or login to share.
  • Show the crew the weekly review now and then, especially when a quote changes because of it.
  • Ask for the reason, not an apology. "Waited for the plasterer" is useful; "sorry" is not.

Always On Tradie does this with GPS check-in and check-out on the job, inside a geofence around the site. If your crew or your work suits it better, you can switch the geofence off and use a single Complete button instead. Every crew member gets their own login at no extra charge, so nobody shares a phone or writes hours on paper.

See booked against actual without the spreadsheet

Doing this in a spreadsheet works, but it means typing up every timesheet first, which is the kind of admin that gets skipped in a busy week. If booked hours come from the schedule and actual hours come from check-ins on site, the comparison is ready without anyone typing it.

In Always On Tradie, the timesheet view shows booked hours against actual hours, and the job's charge sheet shows its markup and profitability. See how it fits into a day of office work the app takes over.

Hours are only half of what a job earns. To check the materials side, read markup vs margin for trades, and to put the lessons into your next price, see how to write a quote for a job.

Questions

How do you calculate labour hours variance?

Subtract the booked hours from the actual hours, then divide by the booked hours and multiply by 100 for a percentage. A job booked at 12 hours that took 15 has a variance of 3 hours, or 25%. Positive means the job ran over.

Should I charge the customer when a job runs over?

On a fixed-price job, only if the extra hours came from extra work the customer asked for, which should be written up and approved as a variation. Overruns from your own estimate or delays are yours to absorb. Use them to price the next similar job better.

How often should I compare booked and actual hours?

Weekly is enough for most trade businesses. It is soon enough that the crew still remember why a job ran over, and regular enough to spot a pattern within a month.

Is GPS check-in the same as tracking my crew all day?

It does not have to be. Check-in and check-out record when someone arrives on and leaves a job site, which is what you need for hours on the job. In Always On Tradie the geofence can be switched off in favour of a single Complete button.

Related reading